Hidden Gems: Uncovering the Best Gluten-Free Pizza Spots in NYC

  • Restaurants, bakeries and other food providers around the US are taking steps to provide good alternatives to people that limit their gluten consumption. 
  • Gluten-free pizza is a variation of the traditional Italian dish – pizza – only made with ingredients that do not contain gluten.
  • Gluten-free pizza crust can be made from alternative ingredients like cauliflower, zucchini, etc.
  • Choose one of the best gluten-free pizzas in NYC, including Joe’s Pizza, Keste Pizza & Vino, Senza Gluten, Risotteria Melloti and Little Beet Table.

We are striving for big transformations in the search for a healthier lifestyle. Gluten-free options have reached sky-high demand in the culinary world, catering to those dealing with gluten intolerance or celiac disease. Restaurants, bakeries and other food providers around the US are taking steps to provide yummy alternatives.

Everyone’s all-time favorite dish pizza has undergone a big transformation in New York City’s rich food scene. The Big Apple is home to countless pizzerias, so finding the best gluten-free pizza in NYC can be a difficult task.

Let’s hop on a journey together to uncover hidden pizza gems serving the best gluten-free pizza in NYC. We go through detailed research and explore the best gluten-free pizza NYC spots, ensuring that even gluten-intolerant people get their rightful slice.

gluten free

Understanding Gluten-Free Pizza

Gluten-free pizza is a variation of the traditional Italian dish only made with ingredients that do not contain gluten. This is very important to people that deal with celiac disease or intolerance to gluten. 

Gluten intolerance actually refers to a medical condition when the body has difficulties digesting the gluten. The most common symptoms of gluten intolerance include bloating, abdominal pain and fatigue.

Another problematic medical condition is celiac disease, an autoimmune disorder triggered by ingestion of gluten and influences the small intestine. Consuming gluten can have serious health implications for those suffering from this disease.

The world is beginning to recognize these medical conditions and is starting to cater to these individuals. By offering gluten-free options, NYC restaurants and pizza places enable those with dietary restrictions to enjoy tasty food without compromising their health.

A survey conducted in 2021 by GIG showed that 38% of the respondents find access to gluten-free food to be a challenge. Today, more and more restaurants recognize this serious problem and offer gluten-free food as part of their menu.

A high number of 42% and 80% of people follow a strict gluten-free diet. There are also around 72% of Americans who fall under the “PWAGs” classification. These are more commonly known as people without celiac disease avoiding gluten. The high demand for the availability of gluten-free options in restaurants is because of the increasing number of PWAGs over the past decade. This is why there are amazing gluten-free pizza NYC options for people affected by gluten consumption.

Types of Gluten-free Crusts    

There are various options on the table that pizza places use to create the best gluten-free pizza NYC crusts. Among the many common options is a crust made from gluten-free flour like rice, corn or almond flour. These crusts tend to be light and crispy, offering a bit of extra flavor and texture similar to traditional pizza dough.

Another alternative is a cauliflower crust. This crust is a combination of cauliflower, eggs and cheese. This crust is often lighter and has a unique flavor profile. Other veggies are also used to replace traditional pizza crust. There are crusts made from alternative grains like quinoa or buckwheat, and they offer a nuttier taste with a slightly denser texture.

Researching the Best Gluten-Free Pizza Spots in NYC 

The quest for finding the best gluten-free pizza NYC spots was not easy. We took a serious approach in conducting thorough research through a number of reviews, articles, online platforms and food blogs. We even went ahead and tried the gluten-free pizza NYC from our shortlisted candidates, so we have first-hand information on our selection.

We took several criteria into account when evaluating the pizza spots. The taste and quality of ingredients, from the crust to the toppings, were carefully assessed by our expert team. In addition, we considered the variety of crust options, menu offerings, and customer reviews. Personal experiences and recommendations from the gluten-free community also influenced our top picks for the best gluten-free pizza NYC.

Joe’s Pizza

There is no escaping from this one. Joe’s Pizza is a renowned NYC pizzeria in Greenwich Village that has been feeding hungry New Yorkers since 1975. This historic pizza place has started serving the best gluten-free pizza in Manhattan, right at Midtown. The prices are affordable, and the variety of toppings you can put on your gluten-free crust is amazing.

Their cauliflower gluten-free crust has been getting rave reviews from customers. A satisfied customer finds Joe’s Pizza delicious and highly recommends the cauliflower crust. They added that one of the staff has celiac disease and understood the cross-contamination issue. Another customer met with the co-owner and discovered that they have a Celiac expert reviewing the prep processes, making Joe’s Pizza one of the absolute best gluten-free pizza in NYC.

Keste Pizza & Vino

pizza with mozzarella cheese toppings

You might have already heard about Keste Pizza & Vino, as it’s a popular choice for gluten-free pizza NYC. This authentic Neapolitan-style pizza spot in the West Village has the best gluten-free pizza in NYC. They offer amazing recipes featuring delicious ingredients, such as pistachio, basil cream, mozzarella and other Italian delicacies. The best part they are gluten-free! What more can one ask for… maybe wine? Worry not — Keste Pizza & Vino also has a great wine selection!

This Neapolitan NYC spot offers many gluten-free options, including different pizzas, lasagna, and more. They get extra points for using a separate oven to prepare their gluten-free pizzas. One happy customer claimed it’s the best gluten-free pizza they ever had, with Kesto Pizza & Vino offering so many options! A customer was amazed and loved the fact that each of the pizza options can be made gluten-free for only $4 extra definitely a place worth visiting.

Senza Gluten

Senza Gluten is one of New York’s highlights for people who don’t consume gluten. Located in Greenwich Village, it’s a specially dedicated gluten-free Italian restaurant in NYC, well-known for its great gluten-free pizza. Senza Gluten uses high-quality gluten-free ingredients, and they have a wide variety of pizza options available to put on the table.

This restaurant definitely deserves a spot on our best gluten-free pizza NYC list and we encourage you to add it to your “must-try” list. Customer reviews claim it’s a spectacular place and strongly recommend the pizza. Well-fed customers call Senza Gluten an outstanding place in all aspects, and it truly is!

Risotteria Melotti

When we talk about hidden gems, the Risotteria Melotti is one of them. A little Italian corner in NYC offering 100% gluten-free traditional Italian cuisine with a twist and amazing gluten-free pizza. They use a unique rice flour-based crust that gives the world’s most famous dish-pizza a unique flavor. In addition, they serve some great creative flavor combinations.

Located in East Village, it’s the best gluten-free pizza in Manhattan. A customer that visited the Risotteria Mellotti referred to it as a gluten-free dream with a lot of options! This cozy little Italian family restaurant makes guests with celiac disease or other gluten-intolerant people feel 100% gluten-free and safe. Customers find it offers a perfectly wonderful experience and excellent food.

Little Beet Table

A hip place named Little Beet Table is the last addition to our list. It’s a cute restaurant that offers great gluten-free pizza options in a trendy setting. They focus on using fresh and locally sourced ingredients and catering to the dietary restrictions of their customers. This trendy Park Avenue restaurant is another “must” in the best gluten-free pizza NYC selection.

Satisfied customers can’t stop talking about NYC’s wholesome and excellent food, recommending the Little Beet Table as a lunch and dinner option. Others refer to the place as a nice small restaurant with delicious food.


chef making pizza dough

For individuals with gluten intolerance or celiac disease, the quest for a mouthwatering slice of pizza often comes with quite a lot of challenges. Traditional pizza dough contains the protein that is found in barley, wheat and rye, and can cause adverse reactions for those with more sensitive organisms.

The culinary scene of New York City is ever-evolving, and a number of hidden gems have emerged that offer exceptional gluten-free pizza options. We recommend one of the above places for the best gluten-free pizza in NYC for their tasty menus, dedication to quality and flavor in their gluten-free pizza options.

Allow yourself unforgettable gluten-free pizza experiences that satisfy your cravings without the side effects of gluten. Accommodating dietary restrictions is important, and that is why we are happy more and more restaurants are joining to prevent the gluten struggle.

Share the good news
Scroll to Top